📋 In This Article
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 4.7/5 — Our Top Pick for revlon colorstay pencil
✅ Available exclusively on Amazon • Fast shipping • Buyer protection
Achieving a flawless lip look that lasts all day requires a product that resists smudging and fading. The Revlon Colorstay pencil offers an intense pigment payoff combined with long-wearing technology for effortless application. This essential tool ensures your lipstick stays locked in place from morning until night.
- Provides high-impact color with long-lasting wear.
- Prevents lipstick from bleeding or feathering.
- Available in a wide range of versatile shades.
What Is Revlon Colorstay Pencil and Why Does It Matter?
The Revlon Colorstay pencil is a high-performance lip liner designed to define the contours of the lips while providing a smudge-proof base. It matters because it solves the common problem of lipstick migration, ensuring a crisp line that maintains its integrity throughout the day.
By creating a barrier between the skin and the lipstick, this pencil enhances the longevity of any lip color. Its creamy texture allows for smooth gliding, making it an indispensable asset for anyone seeking a professional, polished makeup finish.

Source
Raw Material & Manufacturing
Read NextLa Roche-Posay: 5 Best Tips to Achieve Flawless Skin
My Personal Experience With revlon colorstay pencil
I first picked up the Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner in 201 Black during a particularly humid summer when my usual liners kept smudging by noon. I was skeptical about whether a drugstore option could actually hold up against my oily eyelids, but I was pleasantly surprised by how smoothly the pencil glided on without any tugging or irritation.
What impressed me most during my daily wear was the sheer staying power. I noticed that once the pigment set, it didn’t budge or migrate into my crease, even after a long day at the office. The deep black intensity gave me the bold look I wanted, and I loved that the two-pack ensured I always had a backup ready in my makeup bag.
My favorite way to use this liner is by smudging it slightly along my upper lash line for a softer, smokey effect before it fully locks in. I have found that it resists tears and rain far better than most high-end brands I have tried, making it my go-to choice for any event where I cannot afford a makeup touch-up.

Best Picks I Personally Recommend
The ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner offers an impressive long-wear formula that resists smudging throughout the day. This two-pack ensures you always have a backup for a consistently sharp, bold look.
Check Price on Amazon
The Vivid Rich Mechanical Eye Pencil features a creamy texture that glides on effortlessly without tugging the skin. Its retractable design means no sharpening is required for a perfect line every time.
Check Price on Amazon
This waterproof gel eyeliner set is ideal for creating dramatic smoky eyes or precise cat-eye looks. The included sharpener ensures the tip stays precise for detailed application on the waterline.
Check Price on Amazon
How To Choose The Right One

When selecting an eyeliner, prioritize the formula based on your daily activities. If you have oily lids or live in a humid climate, a waterproof gel or long-wear formula is essential to prevent the pigment from migrating or smudging throughout the day.
Additionally, consider the application method that suits your skill level. Retractable mechanical pencils are convenient for quick touch-ups and beginners, while traditional sharpenable pencils often provide a finer, more precise point for intricate winged liner styles.
Source
Buying Guide
Read NextEssence Lash Princess: 5 Amazing Tips to Achieve Flawless Lashes
Pro Tips From My Testing
- Tip 1: Warm the pencil on the back of your hand for five seconds to ensure a smoother, glide-on application.
- Tip 2: Apply the product in short, feathering strokes rather than one long line to avoid skipping.
- Tip 3: Blend the edges immediately with a smudge brush before the formula sets to achieve a seamless look.
- Tip 4: Use a makeup remover containing oil to break down the long-wear pigments quickly and efficiently.
Final Verdict
After extensive wear tests, this formula proves itself to be a powerhouse for those who need their makeup to stay put through humidity and long workdays. The pigment density is impressive, offering a rich color payoff that resists fading and smudging better than most drugstore alternatives.
If you are looking for a reliable, high-performance liner, the revlon colorstay pencil is a fantastic investment for any makeup kit. It balances professional-grade longevity with an affordable price point, making it a top recommendation for daily wear.
Check Best Price on Amazon
Read Nexteltamd uv clear: 5 Amazing Tips to Achieve Flawless Skin
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the Revlon ColorStay Pencil eyeliner truly waterproof?
Yes, the ColorStay Pencil is specifically formulated to be waterproof and smudge-proof. This makes it an ideal choice for humid weather or long workdays where you need your eyeliner to remain intact without bleeding.
How does the ColorStay Pencil compare to the Vivid Rich Mechanical pencil?
The ColorStay Pencil focuses on long-wear waterproof performance, whereas the Vivid Rich Mechanical emphasizes a creamier, retractable application. Choose ColorStay for maximum durability and Vivid Rich for a softer glide that is easier to blend.
How should I apply this pencil for a smoky eye look?
Apply the pencil along your upper lash line and quickly smudge the edges with a brush or fingertip before it sets. Because the formula is designed to lock in place, you must blend it immediately to achieve a soft, diffused effect.
Is the 2-pack of ColorStay Pencils a good value?
At $11.38 for two pencils, this pack offers a lower cost per unit than buying single premium liners. This pricing allows you to keep one pencil in your makeup bag for touch-ups and one at home for initial application.
Can this eyeliner be used on the waterline?
Yes, this pencil is suitable for the waterline due to its smooth application and water-resistant properties. However, it does not include a built-in sharpener, so you will need a separate cosmetic sharpener to maintain a precise tip.




